Category Archives: Choosing Quality

Robots Work for Free

One of the latest GEICO car insurance commercials begins with a sharply dressed mother complaining about the cost of child care, and her choice to use robots to care for her children because they “work for free!” While I admit I laughed when the little girl was squirted in the face as the robot tried to give her a juice box, the parent educator and professional in me says “Whoa!”

Choosing a quality provider isn’t about saving money, but cost is a factor for every family. Cost of care, especially in the current economy, is a huge factor parents face when finding a great match for their child. Infant care in our area typically runs around $190 a week, and that doesn’t take into account centers who go above and beyond our minimum state licensing requirements. Their costs can be higher, but the true “cost” of finding care is in the quality of care provided.

When parents looking for care visit a center or family home provider, I encourage you to do what we learned in grade school: stop, look and listen. Stop and be a child for a moment. Get down on your child’s level. Are there things you can get into that you should not be able to reach? Is the floor clean? Is this an environment you want to be in for eight hours? Do the caregivers smile and look friendly?

Really take a look at the space. Is it bright, colorful and inviting? Are you seeing an environment where your child is going to learn? What activities have the teachers prepared for them? Do they have choices to make throughout the day?

Listen to what the children are saying. Are they enjoying themselves? Are they using indoor voices or are they crying and screaming? How are the teachers conversing with the children? Are they encouraging or berating? Are they nurturing and building relationships with the children?

I am a frugal shopper and love to use coupons and get the freebies as much as anyone else. But when it comes to your most prized possession, your children, don’t settle. Make sure you aren’t going for the “robot care” because it’s free, or letting the cost of care be the only, or even the most important, factor in your decision. When 90 percent of a child’s brain develops before age 5, reflect on what your choice is really going to cost you and your child in the long run.

- Debbie

Photo courtesy of Sarah Gilbert.

Hugs not Handcuffs

4C’s Debbie Bruemmer advocates for discipline, not punishment, when it comes to handling challenging behaviors in children.

My coworker relayed a story to me about a 6-year-old that was handcuffed due to her uncontrollable behavior, and when I went looking for information  I found numerous stories of the same nature in several different states. What are these adults thinking? I thought handcuffs were for hardened criminals.

Then I heard about a child care provider putting a 3-year-old in a “lock-hold” because he didn’t get off a table when she told him to. Thank goodness this happened in front of his mother and she put a stop to it.  While it’s true that children’s behavior isn’t always easy to deal with, we need to rethink these practices.

Young children are always going to test our limits and let’s face it, not every method works for every child. Even in the same family, children have different temperaments and different responses to various discipline techniques.  It kills my older daughter to have her phone taken away even for a few hours, but the younger one could care less about it. Do I send her to her room where she can play Barbies or polish her nails?  No way!

Discipline is not meant to be a way to punish or humiliate your child. It is meant to teach and allow them to learn a lesson,  hopefully gaining self-control over their behavior in the future. You can find parenting advice anywhere: online, from friends, grandparents, pediatricians, from your local resource and referral agency. So what works?  That depends on many factors. 

When it comes to disciplining your child, use T.E.A.C.H. to explore and learn.

  • Tune in to temperament.  Tune in to your child’s uniqueness. Learn to interpret your child’s actions and what sets him or her off.  Is he tired or hungry? Is this behavior telling me my child needs my attention, or asserting his independence? Is she at a developmental stage where such behavior is typical? It’s normal for children with few words in their vocabulary to throw a temper tantrum when frustrated. Give them the words they need to share their feelings.
  • Encourage and praise! Your little one needs your attention and wants to know you love and value them. Catch them being good. Use a firm but calm voice. Redirect with a new activity.
  • Actions speak louder than words. Show your child what is allowed by setting limits rather than telling her ‘no’ all the time. Give her choices. Instead of asking if she’s ready for a bath, ask if she would you like to use the blue or green towel after bath time? Model appropriate  behavior that you would be proud to see in your child. They are watching you!
  • Consequences must be set for each inappropriate behavior. Let your child know ahead of time what you expect and what will occur if your expectation is not met. They will test your limits.  Be consistent. Know your parenting style!  Am I a permissive parent that lets my child do whatever they like?  Am I too busy or tired to set limits with my child? Do I expect perfection?
  • Hugs not handcuffs!  It may seem like a quick fix, but what does it tell your child?

Aren’t Our Kids Worth It?

4C’s Debbie Bruemmer knows parenting can be hard. How can parents support each other, instead of passing judgment?

In a recent news piece, Channel 9 got a lot of community comments about the recent indications that child care vouchers may soon change due to state budget cuts. Those commenting seemed afraid that some people are “getting a free lunch and it has to come to an end.”  I read things like “learn how the rest of us live on minimum wage with no free Daycare,” and “if you can’t afford to care for ‘em, don’t have ‘em!” Am I as a parent supposed to choose not to have children because the cost of child care continues to rise?

What people don’t seem to understand is that child care is expensive whether you make minimum wage or have a decent paying job. Did you know that the average weekly rate for an infant in Southwest Ohio is $205.46 a week? That adds up to over $ 10,000 a year. What I could do with an extra $10,000! And what if I have an infant and a preschooler? Or what if I choose a (NAEYC) nationally quality rated center or one with a state SUTQ rating? The weekly fee is usually more! It’s a Catch-22 in most cases. You need child care in order to go to work and  half or more of your weekly pay goes toward child care expenses.

Funding to assist parents with child care is already fairly minimal. The county or state voucher subsidy system is helpful for some families, but it still isn’t free. Even a working family with two adults and one child can only receive assistance if their cumulative gross income is $27,468 or less (150 percent of federal poverty level) and will have a co-pay. Even that may decrease in July. Headstart programs are available for parents and children who qualify, but space is limited.

So who really pays for the lack of quality care? Your child. My child. When you choose child care for your child, ask yourself, how is my child spending his day? Watching cartoons while a provider chats on the phone or folds her laundry? Or with a nurturing caregiver that knows about child development and plans early learning and age appropriate activities, because he or she has an education and opportunities for professional development? Programs that receive funding from the state and the government may be able to use those dollars on bettering their teachers and the environment; likewise, parents who receive funding assistance have more options for quality care for their children. As with all things, you get what you pay for!

What can parents do? Partly we can help to educate those around us. Respond to editorials and surveys on the news and share your side of the story. Help others understand why quality child care is important to you and your child and the difference it has made for your family. Contact your state representative. Take action now!

My Baby Can Read! Really?

Guest blogger Debbie Bruemmer has a few words of wisdom on early literacy and language development, speaking as a parent and a parent counselor!

We hear it all the time: research tells us how very important the first three years of life are for learning and development.  We have month-by-month milestones and chart after chart to tell us if our baby is on target, or even off the charts!  We push our children at an early age so they can have an advantage for grasping knowledge and “getting ahead” for school readiness.  And now we want our babies to READ.

Earlier this month the TODAY show presented its take on the “Your Baby Can Read” program that hundreds of parents and even child care providers have fallen for. The program claims that a baby as young as three months can learn to read, not just memorize and repeat. Why are programs such as these so appealing to parents?  Obviously, we want our children to succeed!  But my heart almost stopped when I had a child care provider tell me she was using this program as part of her curriculum.

Child development experts tend to agree that the brain of a three-month-old infant is just not developed enough to read, that it is not until a child reaches the age of four or five-years-old that actual reading occurs. Literacy begins by exposing children to language at an early age, thus laying the foundation for readers. Talking to and reading aloud to your infant not only allows for a great bonding experience but creates physical responses in baby as you do so. He may not understand the words you are saying but watch his eye movements, a responsive kick or vocalization.  He hears you!  Hearing leads to listening comprehension which is the predecessor to reading comprehension.

Most babies pass through stages taking them from listening and observing to babbling, on to making words and phrases. Typically, at four-months-old a baby recognizes his or her own name and may coo and make noise when spoken to.  Receptive language (ability to understand what is being said or read) develops  between six to twelve months: babies may imitate sounds, respond to his name, and start  combining syllables into word-like sounds.  An infant’s phonemic awareness (understanding that words are made up of sounds that make different words) comes into play at eight to ten months. By eighteen months they may attempt multi-syllable words and speak three-word sentences.

Communicating with your baby evokes so many more emotive responses than plopping them down in front of a DVD.  It also promotes a closeness between the two of you, fostering emotional development, as well.  I can remember when my babies were little.  There was no greater and more comforting feeling than holding that little baby and singing a lullaby or reading “Goodnight Moon” for the umpteenth time.  Not only was it good for baby, it was good for me, too. A relationship was forming.

Having said all that, why do we think if something is costly, endorsed by someone with a degree, or sounds like a quick fix it must be good? Remember, talk is cheap, in fact, it’s free.  But it just might be the biggest investment you can make for your baby.

According to the National Association for the Education of Young Children(NAEYC) and the International Reading Association (IRA), “the single most important activity for building reading success appears to be reading aloud to children.” The journey to reading begins at birth when parents speak their first adoring words to their baby, not when they pull out the first flash card!

Three Strikes and They’re Out!

Guest blogger Debbie Bruemmer, parent counselor, has been getting a lot of calls lately from parents whose children have been expelled from their centers for reasons you might not believe!

If I were talking about baseball, this might be appropriate, but I’m not! Some child care centers actually have a three bites and you’re out policy, which means children who need help learning appropriate behaviors are instead being expelled from those programs that could be teaching them to respond differently. Biting is a very typical behavior for toddlers, and it’s the duty of teachers and parents to help children learn how to respond to their feelings in a way that hurts less!

I can see where it’s an issue for some centers, that it’s a liability for the other children and a source of exasperation for a teacher that is sometimes caring for as many as ten children. One center that has this policy, however, is a star rated center, and if they don’t know how to help the children who are biting, who does? Children bite for many reasons: feeling frustrated, a limited ability to communicate with words, experimenting with their senses, or testing their limits. If a child is biting, teachers and parents should pay close attention to what is happening around the child when they are biting. Is the child hungry or tired? Is there some stressful situation in the classroom, like a thunderstorm outside, or their parent is late in picking them up?

When a child bites, intervene immediately between the child who is doing the biting and the bitten child. Stay calm and don’t overreact: adults should use their voice and their expression to show that biting is not okay, and should let the child who did the biting help in comforting the bitten child, like getting an ice pack (asking the bitten child first, of course, if they are okay with this).

If you know your child is at the developmental stage where they are biting, talk to the director at your program, talk to the teachers. Make sure that they’re aware and know what to expect, and that they’ve had training in positive discipline techniques. With the right positive reinforcement of desired behaviors, children can learn that biting is not appropriate. If they’re getting expelled after three bites, they’re not being given that opportunity!

Resources: Fact Sheets for Families: Biting

Parents and Teachers Team Up to Care for Children With Special Needs

When a family is dealing with a complex disease or a perplexing disability, the stress and frustration for those involved can be overwhelming.  The challenge of effectively communicating your child’s needs while maintaining clarity with physicians and educators is the juggling act that parents encounter. The following testimony is from one of our staff whose experiences as a family child care provider, a director, and a parent are not unlike those of the parents we serve!  4C is here to support families educationally and supply resources in the 23 counties that we serve.  We strive to encourage a better appreciation of the dynamics involved in a special needs family and how to make it work to the benefit and support of the child.  Parent Counselors are available to assist with an individualized search to support resources available within our community.

Parents of children who exhibit unusual or extreme behaviors are faced with many tough decisions, among them the decision whether or not to medicate their child.   Medications for ADD, ADHD and other disorders are now commonly prescribed for more and increasingly younger children each year.  “But medicine is not always the answer,” says a 4C staff member and mother of a child with special needs. “And even when it is, it’s only part of it.”

That is where caregivers come in. While her son went through multiple diagnoses and a variety of prescriptions, she was lucky enough to foster a relationship with his teachers and develop strategies to help him where medication couldn’t.

She remembers a time when a teacher reported that her young son was acting out in class, climbing on top of desks and making a scene. She was shocked. Her son was usually reserved, more likely to suffer from shyness than outbursts like the ones described.

“Misbehavior isn’t always what it seems to be,” she cautions. The source of her son’s behavior that day turned out to be anxiety about a field trip. He assumed that if he misbehaved, he would be forbidden to go. Sometimes caregivers need to dig a little deeper, ask questions, and devise solutions unique to the child instead of what might be standard practice.

One strategy: letting him stand at his desk: “Standing was his teacher’s idea,” says this  former family child care provider and director of a child care center. “She asked me, ‘How does he eat dinner at home?’ We’d always let him stand. It never occurred to me to share this with his teacher, but we started to work as a team. It takes a really good relationship to make sure that you both understand what you’re seeing in the child.”

The more children are medicated, the more it seems like this is the first and best option, the only option for a child who just won’t sit still, or who throws severe temper tantrums, or is painfully shy. With her experiences as a mother and a child care provider, this 4C staff member knew that her son needed more than medication, that all children do.

“There was no magic bullet,” she says. “He needed strategies. It wasn’t just the medication or just the behavior management plan. We had to find a way to make them work together, and to work as parents with the teachers and relatives who cared for him.” Another strategy: encouraging him to carry a fidget in his pocket.

Patti Craig, 4C consultant and program manager of Promoting Resilient Children in Cincinnati, knows that these situations can be complicated. “All behaviors represent feelings, stress and anxiety,” she says. “Understanding what those are, instead of just disciplining the behavior, gives you a much clearer picture of what’s happening for the child.”

Patti also knows  that sharing concerns with parents can be difficult, and advises that teachers should work from day one to establish a rapport with families. “First sharing the strengths of the child with their families will make it easier to have those more difficult discussions later about behavior or concerns,” she says. “We all want the same things for children in terms of success, and if we stay focused on that vision instead of the specific behavior or concern, we can develop a much more appropriate plan that everyone participates in.”

Beginning with observation and information gathering, a teacher can build a picture of the whole child: how a child transitions, communicates, his or her ability to engage in learning. If a child is stressed or anxious, it’s important for a teacher to understand why, to ask questions of parents and examine those troubling behaviors in the context where they occur. If a child is biting, when are they biting? During pick-up and drop-off times? When they are vying for a parent’s attention?

When parents and teachers share common ground and communicate freely, effective strategies can be developed. Strategies like the ones devised for the 4C staff member’s son were crucial not only in helping him adjust and grow, but also in helping  the family and his teachers give him the best care possible.

“Now my son is medication free,” she says. Though medication was part of his plan for success, his positive growth and his ability to perform socially and academically was made possible by a collaboration between teacher and parent.

Know more about buying a car than choosing quality child care? New study shows that ‘picking a lemon’ when it comes to child care has lasting impact

Quality really matters in child care. This week a widely-reported new study shows that the quality of child care has effects that persist into adolescence.

Teenagers who had been in higher-quality care were less likely to report problem behaviors such as arguing, being mean and getting into fights. Teens who had been in low-quality care settings were found to have more obedience and academic problems that persisted through age 15.

The research was based on 1,300 children in a federally-funded study. The researchers collected information about the type and quality of care the children received birth through age 4½. All types of care were included from parents, to nannies, to child care centers.

This study speaks to the importance of making sound choices for child care. So what’s a parent to do?  Take the same approach as buying a car: study up on makes and models, read Consumer Reports and take a few test drives. Then make a choice.

Translated to child care: learn the indicators of quality care, get a checklist, visit and observe, check for quality indicators such as accreditation or a state star rating.  For child care checklists and further information visit: www.4cforchildren.org/Parents/ChoosingQuality.

–Elaine

Posted by 4cforchildren on Monday, May 17, 2010 10:00 AM

What Good Is Play Anyway?

Why is play such a big part of most early childhood programs?  It’s the foundation for planning, flexible thinking, strengthening memory skills, problem solving, self-control, persistence, the ability to use symbols, and much more.  It’s clear:  when you watch children play, alone or with others, you’re watching development occur.  When you support and encourage play, you’re helping development occur.

Look around…you might even spot a local expert on play sitting under a kitchen table.  That’s where I found my daughter at the age of three playing with some toy animals and a cake pan.  After numerous minutes of watching the horse, zebra and giraffe all take a drink from the cake pan…I observed the following:

*practiced planning as she decides where each animal will stand. *used flexible thinking as she solves the problem of making the giraffe stand up. *memorized the original order of the animals and recreated it after moving them. *engaged in symbolic thought and representation by pretending the cake pan is a pond and the toys are real animals. *strengthened her self-control and her ability to be persistent by overcoming her annoyance at the giraffe.

Early childhood programs take play seriously for a good reason…play is important!                                                     Karen

Posted by karen on Monday, November 09, 2009 10:48 PM